Tag Archive for: Hague attorney USA

Hague Convention Case Review: Northern District of Illinois / Ireland: Memorandum Opinion and Order

In this recent Hague Convention case that concluded in the Northern District of Illinois, Masters Law Group championed the rights of the petitioner in a challenging international family law matter. 

The case, resolved on August 29, 2024, through a carefully negotiated settlement, highlights the complexity and emotional weight of cross-border parental disputes. This resolution highlights the vital role of international law, particularly the Hague Convention, in helping protect the best interests of children caught between borders.

Case Overview: Northern District of Illinois / Ireland

This Hague Decision revolves around a dispute between the petitioner and the respondent. During a recent video status hearing before Judge Edmond E. Chang, the parties’ counsel, confirmed that they had reached a settlement agreement with the assistance of Masters Law Group attorneys and a magistrate judge. The agreement was detailed in a term sheet submitted to the court.

Key elements of the settlement include the following:

  1. Passport Handover: As part of the settlement, it was agreed that the child’s passport, currently held by the respondent, would be promptly handed over to the petitioner’s counsel. The passport will then be returned to the respondent at the airport on August 31, 2024. The parties agreed to travel back to Dublin, Ireland, on that date.
  2. Next Steps: The court has instructed the petitioner’s counsel to file a status report or a stipulation of dismissal consistent with the settlement agreement’s terms during the week of September 2, 2024. Additionally, a tracking status hearing is scheduled for September 6, 2024. This hearing is to help ensure the settlement is progressing as planned. It’s important to note that no court appearance will be required from the parties.

This settlement reflects the complexity of international parental disputes, where issues of child custody, cross-border travel, and international law converge.

The Role of the Hague Convention

The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction is at the heart of many international parental disputes. It provides a legal framework for promptly returning a child to their country of habitual residence, where custody matters can be properly adjudicated.

In cases like the Northern District of Illinois / Ireland, the Hague Convention is a tool for determining the jurisdictional authority. It also helps ensure that international child abduction does not occur under the guise of custody disputes. The Hague Convention aims to deter international parental child abduction by establishing clear guidelines for the prompt return of the child to their home country, where local courts can then decide custody and visitation issues.

In this case, the settlement terms—including the return of the child’s passport and the agreed travel back to Dublin, Ireland—align with the principles of the Hague Convention. The agreement ensures compliance with international law and helps protect the child’s best interests by facilitating the child’s return to their habitual residence.

The Importance of Legal Guidance in International Custody Disputes

Cases involving international parental disputes, such as the Northern District of Illinois / Ireland, highlight the importance of having legal guidance in navigating complex situations where multiple jurisdictions and international laws intersect. The Hague Convention provides a framework, but the specific circumstances of each case can vary widely, requiring tailored legal strategies.

Working alongside an experienced attorney can help protect a child’s welfare while ensuring compliance with international treaties and local laws. Families facing similar challenges should consult with a Hague Convention attorney with experience in international family law.

Case Results

The court set a tracking status hearing for September 6, 2024, but indicated that no appearance is required. This suggests that the court does not anticipate further issues requiring a hearing. If everything proceeds according to the settlement, the court will record the case as resolved and dismissed.

The settlement agreement promotes a balanced co-parenting arrangement, helping ensure consistent and meaningful contact between the child and both parents. The agreement also encourages cooperation on matters of citizenship and legal concerns. This resolution reflects a collaborative approach to prioritizing the child’s best interests.

READ THE FULL CASE REVIEW HERE.


Hague Convention Law With Masters Law Group

At Masters Law Group, we bring experience handling sensitive international family law cases, including those involving the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction. Our team is committed to helping protect the rights of parents and children involved in cross-border disputes.

Our Hague Convention attorneys, Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph, possess comprehensive knowledge in navigating cases under the Hague Convention, enacted through the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (ICARA). If you are facing child abduction proceedings under the Hague Convention, we are here to help. Contact Masters Law Group today to schedule your complimentary consultation.

Explore our featured Hague Convention case decisions here.

Masters Law Group Case Review: Western District of Michigan/Brazil

At Masters Law Group, we are committed to protecting the rights of parents and children under international law. In our most recent Hague Convention case, we successfully negotiated a favorable resolution for our client, helping ensure the child’s best interests were prioritized.

In this case, which concluded on August 23, 2024, the respondent—represented by Masters Law Group—sought the return of his child, who had been taken from the United States. Masters Law Group, experienced in navigating complex international child custody disputes, recently represented the respondent in a case filed in the Western District of Michigan.

Case Overview: Western District of Michigan / Brazil

On August 23, 2024, the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Michigan approved an agreement between the parties involved. Masters Law Group represented the respondent, who was defending his right to retain his child in the United States. The case concerned whether the child was wrongfully removed or retained from their habitual residence and the appropriate legal remedies to be enforced.

Legal Framework and Key Issues

The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (“The Hague Convention”) aims to protect children from international abduction by ensuring their prompt return to their country of habitual residence. In this case, the Petitioner sought the return of her child under the Convention, asserting that the child’s removal from Brazil to the United States was wrongful and violated custody rights under Brazilian law.

The primary issue in this case was determining whether the child should be returned to Brazil or if an alternate custody arrangement should be made to serve the child’s best interests. After thorough negotiation, both parties reached a comprehensive stipulation, which the court approved, effectively resolving the dispute. For the reasons stated below, the Court orders that the stipulation be approved and adopted.

The Stipulation Agreement

A stipulation and order is a legal document in which the parties involved in a case agree on certain facts, procedures, or actions and then submit this agreement to the court for approval. Once approved, the stipulation becomes an official court order. The stipulation agreement, in this case, establishes several key provisions to help ensure the well-being of the child and the rights of both parents:

  1. Child Custody: A custody order will be established simultaneously in Brazil and Michigan. The child will live with the mother during the school year and stay with the father during school breaks (summer, winter, and spring).
  2. Visitation and Communication: The father has visitation rights during school breaks in Brazil. The child will communicate daily with the other parent via WhatsApp.
  3. Transportation: Parents will share transportation responsibilities for parenting exchanges. The parent starting their time with the child will handle transportation.
  4. School Arrangements: The child will begin school in Michigan, staying with the father until December 27, 2024. After that, the child will virtually finish the first school semester in Brazil.
  5. Parental Access During Visits: Both parents agree to make the child available for parenting time when the other parent is visiting.
  6. Extracurricular Activities: The child may continue playing soccer while in Brazil.
  7. Passports and Citizenship: Both parents will cooperate in obtaining U.S. and Brazilian passports and dual citizenship for the child.
  8. Attorney Fees: Each parent will be responsible for their attorney fees and costs.
  9. Jurisdiction: The court will retain jurisdiction to enforce the terms until both parties agree to dismiss the matter.

Case Results

The final agreement promotes a balanced parenting arrangement, helping provide consistent contact between the child and both parents. A parenting arrangement helps foster cooperation on citizenship and legal matters. This resolution reflects a collaborative approach to co-parenting, prioritizing the child’s best interests and providing clear guidelines for both parties moving forward. The U.S. District Court for the Western District of Michigan approved and adopted this stipulation as an official court order. Making all agreed-upon terms enforceable under its jurisdiction. 

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the above stipulation is approved and adopted as an order of this court.

Date: August 23, 2024.

READ THE FULL CASE HERE.


Navigating International Family Law 

For families facing the complexities of international child custody disputes, it’s crucial to have experienced legal representation. With Masters Law Group by your side, navigating these challenging circumstances becomes more manageable. Your child’s safety is our top priority, and our team of attorneys can help you protect yourself and your children.

Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph have extensive knowledge and experience in cases involving the Hague Convention, enacted through the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (“ICARA”).  They are uniquely positioned to help guide you through the legal process and fight for your child’s return to their rightful home.

 Contact us today to schedule your complimentary consultation.

Check out our featured Hague Decisions here.

Masters Law Group Hague Convention Case Review: The District of Iowa / Mexico

International parental abduction is a complex and emotionally charged issue that affects families worldwide. At Masters Law Group, we are committed to protecting the rights of parents and children under international law. In our most recent Hague Convention case, we succeeded in a landmark ruling in favor of our client.

In this case, which concluded on August 27, 2024, the respondent—represented by Masters Law Group—sought the return of her child, who had been taken from the United States. The Hague Convention helps protect children from international abduction. It allows a parent to petition for the return of their child to the country of habitual residence when wrongful removal or retention occurs.

Legal Framework and Key Issues

The Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (“The Hague Convention”) is designed to protect children from international abduction by helping ensure their prompt return to their habitual residence. To succeed in a petition under the Convention, the petitioner must establish that the child was wrongfully removed from their habitual residence and that the removal violated custody rights under the law of the habitual residence country. In this case, the key issues revolved around determining the child’s habitual residence, whether the petitioner had consented to the child’s removal, and whether returning the child to Mexico would pose a grave risk to their safety.

For the reasons stated below, the Court ACCEPTS and ADOPTS the Report and Recommendation. The Amended Petition is DENIED. [ECF No. 5].

Case Overview

The parties’ relationship began in 2015, and they have since lived in various states in the U.S. before relocating to Mexico in 2023. In November 2023, the respondent took the child back to the United States, citing concerns for their safety, and sought a protective order against the petitioner. The order, granted by an Iowa state court, effectively barred the petitioner from contact with the respondent and their child, E.L.S., until November 2024, requiring the child to remain in Iowa. This led to the petitioner filing under the Hague Convention, claiming that the child was wrongfully removed from Mexico, the country of habitual residence.

Case Background

The court found that the child’s habitual residence was in the United States, not Mexico. Although the family had lived in Mexico briefly, the court determined that the child had not fully acclimated to life there. Factors such as the child’s young age, the short duration of residence in Mexico, and the family’s strong ties to the United States played a crucial role in this determination. The court concluded that the child was more “at home” in the United States, where she had spent most of her life.

The court examined whether the petitioner had consented to the child’s retention in the United States. The protective order issued by the Iowa state court, to which the petitioner had consented, included a provision that the child was to remain in Iowa until further orders. The court interpreted this consent as a concession to the child’s retention in the United States.

The respondent argued that returning the child to Mexico would expose her to a grave risk of physical or psychological harm due to the domestic violence she had experienced from the petitioner. The court found sufficient evidence of such a risk, considering the documented history of violence between the parties. The court concluded that returning the child to Mexico would indeed place her in an intolerable situation.

Case Results

After reviewing the evidence and legal arguments, the court accepted and adopted the Report and Recommendation. The court ruled that the petitioner had not proven that Mexico was the child’s habitual residence and that the child was wrongfully removed. Additionally, the defenses of acquiescence and grave risk were sufficiently established. As a result, the court denied the Amended Petition for the Return of the Child to Mexico.

The case is hereby closed.

Date: August 27, 2024.

READ THE FULL CASE REVIEW HERE.


Hague Convention Law With Masters Law Group

Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph have vast knowledge and experience with the Hague Convention, which was enacted through the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (“ICARA”). Parents whose child has been wrongfully removed from or retained in the United States must petition for the child’s return.

If you are facing child abduction proceedings under the Hague Convention, Masters Law Group can help. Contact us today to schedule a consultation.

Check out our featured Hague Decisions here.

Hague Convention Attorneys in Action

At Masters Law Group, our Hague Convention attorneys have extensive experience handling complex international disputes.

Navigating international family law can be complex and challenging, especially when it comes to child abduction disputes. The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, aka the Hague Convention, is an international treaty that protects children from parental abduction across international borders. This blog will highlight rulings demonstrating the Convention’s effectiveness in resolving cross-border disputes.

Join us as we explore the legal framework, showing how it translates into real-world victories and how our Hague Convention attorneys can assist you. Here’s what you need to know.

UNDERSTANDING THE HAGUE CONVENTION

The Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction was enacted into law through the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (“ICARA”). It provides that a parent whose child has been wrongfully removed from the U.S. can petition for the child’s return to their country of habitual residence. Each country appoints central authorities to help resolve these disputes. As of 2024, there are 91 countries involved in the Hague Convention.

Families need to understand the importance of the Hague Convention when they find themselves involved in international disputes. Here are some tips to follow if you find yourself in this situation:

  • Prompt action is crucial: If you believe your child has been wrongfully removed or retained in a Hague Convention country, it is essential to act promptly. Initiating legal proceedings increases the chances of a successful resolution.
  • Contact the central authority: In the United States, the Office of Children’s Issues within the U.S. Department of State is the foremost authority for Hague Convention matters. They can provide information, resources, and assistance locating and returning your child.
  • Gather evidence: It is essential to gather evidence demonstrating your child’s habitual residence and the wrongful removal or retention. Documentation such as birth certificates and communication records can strengthen your case.
  • Consulting with a family law attorney: A family law attorney with experience in Hague law is recommended. They can guide you through the legal process and help you navigate the complexities of the Hague Convention.

Dealing with international disputes can be emotionally demanding, so preparing for the challenges is essential. Working with a Hague Convention attorney can provide valuable support. Now, let’s explore some recent Hague Convention cases to see how these principles are applied in real-world situations.

CASE 1: DISTRICT OF COLORADO / COLOMBIA: AGUIRRE

In our most recent case that concluded on February 20, 2024, the husband – represented by Masters Law Group –  filed a petition to return his two children. His children were taken from his residence in Colombia to the United States by their mother. The parties were married in the United States in 2012 and lived together in Colombia. 

The Respondent took the children to the U.S. for a family reunion but faced delays in their passport renewal. This case arises under the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (ICARA), 42 U.S.C. § 11601 et seq., which implements the Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction.

This Act allows a person whose child has been removed from his custody in another country and taken to the United States to petition in federal or state court for the return of the child. The court would later find in favor of the Petitioner, concluding that the Respondent wrongfully retained the children and dismissing her claim of grave risk of harm. The Petitioner’s request for the return of the children to Colombia is granted.

CASE 2: EASTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN / MEXICO: HINNENDAEL

In the Eastern District of Wisconsin / Mexico, Hinnendael, the father of the children (Petitioner), sought to relocate his children back to the United States from Mexico against the other parent’s wishes.

The court found that returning the children would subject them to a grave risk of psychological harm or otherwise place them in an intolerable situation. Accordingly, the retention of children in the United States was not wrongful within the meaning of the Convention. The petition was denied, and this action was dismissed.

By invoking the Hague Convention, our attorneys successfully advocated for the children. This case helps highlight the effectiveness of the Hague Law in resolving child abduction cases and prioritizing the children’s welfare.

CASE 3: NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS / NEW ZEALAND: H.O.

In the Northern District of Illinois / New Zealand, Ho, the husband – represented by our firm –  filed a petition for the return of his child. The child was taken from his residence in New Zealand to the United States by his wife – the mother of the child. As relevant here, the Hague Convention provides that a parent whose child has been wrongfully removed or retained in the United States may petition for the child’s return to their country of habitual residence.

By agreement of the parties and as required by the Convention, the court concludes that the child was a habitual resident of New Zealand at the time of the wrongful retention in the United States. The Petitioner exercised parental responsibility rights under New Zealand law, and this case did not establish the “grave risk” exception.

The court granted the petition for the child’s return to New Zealand and allowed an approximate one-week period to avoid any abrupt transition for the child. This case demonstrated the Hague Law’s role in helping ensure fairness, predictability, and respect for due process in international child abduction cases.

CASE 4:NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS / LITHUANIA: SULCAITE

In the Northern District of Illinois / Lithuania, Sulcaite Masters Law Group helped resolve the wrongful removal of children. The courts considered the parents’ last shared intent to their child’s country of residence.

The Respondent and the Petitioner agreed that their children would reside in Chicago temporarily. After three years, they were to return to Lithuania, their country of origin.

However, as time passed, the children became acclimated to their new life in the United States. Their mother’s remarriage and new baby created a strong family bond, and Chicago gradually became their familiar home. Considering these factors, the court denied the Petitioner for the children’s return. The decision reflected a recognition of the children’s well-being and stability, prioritizing their best interests.

This case showcases the effective advocacy of our Hague Convention attorneys in navigating complex international disputes. The legal team successfully obtained a favorable outcome for the parties involved by presenting compelling evidence.

CASE 5: NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA / CYPRUS: EFTHYMIOU V. LABONTE

In the Northern District of California / Cyprus, the husband – represented by Masters Law Group –  filed a petition to return his child, who was taken from Cyprus to the United States by his wife – the child’s mother. The child’s father (Petitioner) had full parental rights to the child since his parents’ separation in 2014. The minor came to the United States for a six-week visit with his mother (Respondent) in California. At the end of the visit, the Petitioner came to collect his son but was unsuccessful.

Nearly one week after the scheduled meet-up went awry, the child’s father filed a Hague Convention plea. The court granted the petition and ordered the child to return to Cyprus in the custody of his father. In addition, the court did not impose a longer stay without agreement from both sides. The court ultimately ordered the return of a child under an action under U.S.C.S.C. § 9003.

These cases showcase our commitment to navigating international child abduction disputes and achieving favorable outcomes for our clients.

WORK WITH OUR HAGUE CONVENTION ATTORNEYS

The Hague Convention continues to play a pivotal role in reuniting families affected by parental child abduction. At Masters Law Group, we understand the complexities of international child abduction disputes and the importance of finding a resolution that aligns with your objectives.

Our Hague Convention attorneys will tirelessly advocate for your interests and work towards a favorable outcome. We prioritize open communication with our clients and strive to provide personalized attention to address your concerns.

To learn more about how we can help you, schedule your complimentary consultation today.

Understanding International Parental Child Abduction on Missing Children’s Day

May 25th, 2024, is National Missing Children’s Day, a reminder of the importance of child safety and the prevention of child abductions. For parents, guardians, and all those invested in the safety of children, vigilance is vital. 

Despite concerted efforts, parental child abductions persist, with international cases posing particularly daunting challenges. Shockingly, family abductions alone make up 49 percent of all child abduction cases, underscoring the gravity of the issue. The heartache endured by both the abducted child and the left-behind parent is truly unimaginable.

In this blog, we will explore the complexities of international parental child abduction, providing you with essential knowledge and resources should you ever confront this distressing scenario. Here’s what you need to know.

National Missing Children’s Day

National Missing Children’s Day is a solemn occasion emphasizing ongoing efforts to protect and defend children nationwide. This day, established by President Ronald Reagan on May 25, 1983, pays tribute to the brave endeavors of various agencies, organizations, and individuals dedicated to protecting children’s safety.

The origin of National Missing Children’s Day lies in the disappearance of 6-year-old Etan Patz from New York City on May 25, 1979. Etan’s case not only shocked the nation but also catalyzed efforts to address the issue of missing children on a national scale. On this day, we remember him and acknowledge the unwavering dedication of those who tirelessly work to reunite families and protect children.

Let’s turn our attention to a crucial aspect of child safety: understanding the signs of parental child abduction. By identifying these indicators, we can help better protect our children and take proactive steps to prevent such heartbreaking situations.

Knowing The Signs Of Parental Child Abduction

Being able to identify the red flags that signal parental child abduction is crucial when it comes to preventing these tragic scenarios. Family members can often be the perpetrators, as they may believe they know what is best for the child. Young children are particularly vulnerable targets as they may not know how to seek help or alert others if their parent takes them.

It is essential to be mindful of warning signs and factors that may increase the likelihood of parental child abduction, including:

  1. Threats and Previous Incidents: Any previous threats of seriously hiding your child are critical, as these behaviors can escalate to abduction.
  2. Weak Ties to Current Location: Parents with limited connections to their current community, unstable employment, or distant family may feel more inclined to relocate with the child.
  3. Strong Affiliation with Another Country: Keep an eye on parents with strong emotional or familial ties to another country, especially if they have lived there previously or frequently express a desire to return.
  4. Recent Unexplained Changes in Behavior: Sudden and unexplained actions like quitting a job, selling property, closing bank accounts, or applying for passports or visas should raise concerns, as they could indicate plans for abduction.
  5. History of Relationship Struggles or Domestic Violence: In some cases, parents who perceive themselves as wronged in the relationship may resort to abduction as a means of retaliation.

By recognizing these red flags, we can take proactive steps to help protect our children and prevent the devastating consequences of parental child abduction.

How To Keep Children Safe

Helping secure the safety of our children involves proactive steps and swift action when needed. Establishing clear parental responsibilities and visitation plans is crucial. Reporting a parenting dispute to appropriate authorities, such as local law enforcement or a state judicial officer, is vital for accountability and expedited resolution.

There are also great aids available besides the local authorities. Reaching out to resources like the Department of State’s Office of Children’s Issues and the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC) can provide support. NCMEC collaborates closely with government agencies and administers programs like the Victim Reunification Travel Program.

To further help mitigate the risk of parental child abduction or enhance the chances of recovering a missing child, consider the following gathering the following:

  • Up-to-date pictures of your child.
  • Fingerprints of your child.
  • A written detailed description of your child, including height, weight, hair color, eye color, birthmarks, and noticeable physical characteristics.
  • Copies of your child’s Social Security card and passport.

By collaboratively taking these measures, we can collectively contribute to helping safeguard the safety and well-being of all children. Additionally, seeking guidance from a seasoned child abduction attorney with Hague Convention case experience can help navigate such challenging situations.

How The Hague Convention Can Help

The Hague Convention is an international agreement that provides a legal framework for the prompt return of children who have been wrongfully removed or retained outside their home country. The Convention guarantees that parents must return children involved in international custody cases to their habitual residence. This deters parents from attempting to relocate children across borders without the other parent’s consent or a court order.

The original Hague Conventions of 1899 and 1907 were massive, multi-part international treaties that established certain guidelines of international law, including rules of engagement that countries agreed to follow during times of war. In the decades since, many additional Hague conventions have taken place, and the Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH) was established as a permanent organization with the goal of establishing and supporting a set of unified international laws.

Each section and installment of the Hague Conventions has been signed, ratified, and entered into force by a different selection of countries. As such, any list of “Hague countries” based upon a single convention would be suspect and inadequate. However, as of March 2022, the HCCH itself includes 91 permanent members: 90 countries (nearly all of which are also members of the United Nations) and the European Union itself, which is classified as a “Regional Economic Integration Organisation (REIO). HCCH also includes 65 “connected parties” which are not full members, but are either in the process of becoming a member or have signed, ratified or agreed to observe one or more HCCH Conventions (full list can be found here).

How Does The Hague Convention Work?

The left-behind parent can initiate legal proceedings for the child’s return when someone wrongfully removes or retains them in a Hague Convention country. The central authority in the country where the child is located, such as the U.S. Department of State’s Office of Children’s Issues, plays a crucial role in coordinating efforts to find the child and facilitate their return.

Under the Hague Convention, the child’s return is the primary objective, and the legal proceedings focus on determining the child’s habitual residence and whether their removal or retention violated the custody rights of the left-behind parent. The Hague Convention does not address custody or visitation rights issues but instead focuses on the prompt return of the child to their country of habitual residence. 

Click here to see the participating countries of the treaty. 

Working With A Child Abduction Attorney

International custody disputes are almost always extremely complex and delicate situations, and you should not attempt to navigate them without the assistance of a knowledgeable and experienced child abduction attorney. A family law attorney well-versed in child abductions can provide crucial assistance in filing Hague Convention applications and help defend against lawsuits under the Convention.

Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph have extensive experience in cases involving international child custody disputes in both courts located in the State of Illinois and the United States federal court system. We have extensive knowledge and experience with The Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (“The Hague Convention”) that was enacted into law through the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (“ICARA”), which provides that a parent whose child has been wrongfully removed from or retained in the United States may petition for the child’s return to his or her country of habitual residence.

See our Featured Hague Decisions here:

Last Thoughts

National Missing Children’s Day reminds us of our ongoing efforts to reunite missing children with their families. One significant step towards this goal is for the U.S. and other countries to participate in the Hague Convention, which helps enable the negotiation of treaties to streamline international justice.

When dealing with international child custody/abduction cases, it’s essential to have the support of a knowledgeable family law attorney who understands the intricacies of the international legal system. With our guidance, you can navigate the complex legal processes involved in The Hague Convention and work toward a fast resolution, prioritizing the child’s well-being.

Contact us here today to learn more.

Do Parental Responsibilities Fall Under The Hague Convention?

Parental responsibility cases can be emotionally challenging and legally complex, especially when situations arise that involve parental child abduction. When family disputes span across national or international borders, the Hague Convention can prove a valuable resource for the parent left behind.

While the main goal of the Hague Convention is to secure the prompt return of children wrongfully removed to or retained in any country (which is not the child’s country of habitual residence), it does not affect or impact the decision-making process regarding custody issues (allocation of parental responsibilities), nor does it focus on the underlying merits of a custody dispute. Rather, it determines under what circumstances a child should be returned to a country for custody proceedings under that country’s laws.

Understanding how this convention applies to parental responsibility cases is crucial for parents recently filing for divorce or separation who have international connections. Unfortunately, some parents never accept the divorce and purposely cause problems, sometimes by taking their child far away from the other parent. 

PARENTAL RESPONSIBILITY AND PARENTING PLANS

In Illinois, the landscape of parental arrangements has evolved. “Allocation of Parental Responsibilities” includes the division of decision-making responsibility, previously known as “legal custody,” and parenting time, previously known as “visitation,” amongst the parties.  Parenting plans outline the schedule dictating a child’s interactions with each parent after a divorce or separation. 

Without a parenting plan, no official documentation exists specifying where a child should be at any given time. This legal void can lead to situations where parents can, without repercussion, abandon their children or take them away without the explicit consent of the other parent. In the state of Illinois, according to 720 ILCS Sec. 10-5(b)(6), a parent can abduct their child if, absent a custodial order/parenting plan, “knowingly conceals” a child “for 15 days and fails to make reasonable attempts within the 15 days to notify the other parent.” Let’s take a look at how Illinois grants custody.

HOW ILLINOIS GRANTS CUSTODY

Approximately 40% of states in the United States strive to provide equal custody time for both parents. Courts consider the child’s best interests when determining parenting arrangements. They aim to confirm that the child maintains a strong and healthy relationship with both parents.

They consider the child’s age, needs, and each parent’s ability to provide a safe environment. The court may select a mother over a father if the father negatively impacts the child or vice versa. Having clear guidelines and agreements can help establish stability and promote effective co-parenting. If you are a parent facing international parental child abduction, or feel your family is at risk of such an event, let’s look at how the Hague Convention could help.

“RIGHTS OF CUSTODY” UNDER THE HAGUE CONVENTION

As previously mentioned, the Convention does not affect or impact the decision-making process regarding custody issues (allocation of parental responsibilities), nor does it focus on the underlying merits of a custody dispute. However, it aims to secure the prompt return of children who have been wrongfully removed to or retained in any contracting state and distinguishes between the remedies available to protect “rights of custody” and “rights of access.”

  • “Rights of custody” includes rights relating to the care of the child and the right to determine the child’s place of residence.
  • “Rights of access” includes the right to take the child for a period of time – Article 5(a).

The Convention protects rights of access without an order of return, but in some circumstances, an “access parent” may be considered to hold rights of custody and thus be entitled to an order for the child’s return under the Convention.

PROTECTING PARENTAL RESPONSIBILITIES ACROSS BORDERS

The Hague Convention sets out clear procedures for determining where the child normally lives and dealing with wrongful removal or retention cases. Each country appoints central authorities to resolve disputes, and courts in both the child’s home country and the country where they’re in decide on the best course of action. 

If the Convention states if the removal or retention was wrongful, then the court must order the child returned to his or her habitual residence for a custody determination, unless the responding parent (the parent who removed or retained the child ) can establish one of the following:

  1. More than one year has passed since the wrongful removal or retention and the child is settled in his or her new environment
  2. The petitioning parent was not actually exercising custody rights at the time of the removal or retention
  3. The petitioning parent had consented to or subsequently acquiesced in the removal or retention
  4. The child objects to being returned and is of an age and maturity level at which it is appropriate to take account of his or her views
  5. There is a “grave risk” that the child’s return “would expose the child to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place the child in an intolerable situation,” or
  6. The return of the child would be inconsistent with “fundamental principles … relating to the protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms.”

Overall, the Hague Convention helps maintain stability and consistency in parenting arrangements while protecting the rights of children and parents involved in cross-border disputes.

CHALLENGES TO CONSIDER

Parents often face hurdles when dealing with international parenting disputes. One of the most significant challenges is simply navigating another country’s legal system. This can involve language barriers, unfamiliar legal procedures, and cultural differences, making it difficult for parents to advocate for their rights effectively. 

Additionally, parents may struggle to locate and communicate with their children, especially if the other parent is hiding them. In some cases, parents may also face obstacles related to travel, such as visa restrictions or prohibitive travel costs. International parental responsibility cases can be highly stressful and emotionally taxing for parents. That’s why having the right support and guidance is essential throughout the process.

GETTING THE HELP YOU NEED

The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction can be a valuable resource for resolving abduction cases involving international borders, prioritizing their well-being. 

But to navigate these complex cases successfully, seeking legal counsel with knowledge and experience in Hague proceedings is extremely valuable. Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph have extensive experience in cases involving international parental disputes in courts located in the State of Illinois and the United States federal court system. 

Our profound understanding and proficiency with The Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (“The Hague Convention”), enacted into law through the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (“ICARA”), empowers us to help advocate thoroughly and effectively. 

Highlighted Hague Decisions:

Contact us today to schedule a consultation.

Demystifying the Hague Convention: Essential FAQs Answered

The nightmare of having your child taken across borders is a frightening reality for a growing number of parents across the globe. Under the Hague Convention, solutions are provided for parents who seek the return of their child to their country of habitual residence.

International Parental Child Abduction is an act of illegally taking a child from their residing home by one of the parents across international borders. If you suspect the possible scenario of International Parental Child Abduction in your family, here are some questions and answers that can provide valuable insight.

1. What is the Hague Convention?

The Hague Convention was enacted into law through the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (ICARA). This law provides help to parents whose child or children have been wrongfully removed from or retained in their custody. They may petition for the child’s return to their country of habitual residence.

This Hague treaty was developed by the Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH) and entered into force in December 1983. There are over 93 countries that participate in the treaty. This treaty governs the way other countries’ legal systems work together. There were two specific goals in mind at the time of The Hague Services Convention’s formation:

  • Create a means to help ensure judicial and extrajudicial documents to be served abroad can be brought to the notice of the addressee in sufficient time.
  • Improve the organization of mutual judicial assistance.

2. What Is “Wrongful Removal” Under The Hague Convention?

Deciding whether to file a Hague application is a big decision. It depends on the specific circumstances of each case. A wrongful removal or retention of a child is considered illegal if it violates your custodial rights and you were exercising those rights at the time of the removal or retention.

In order for the Hague Convention to apply, it must have been in force between the two countries when the wrongful removal occurred. When a country joins the Convention, it doesn’t automatically partner with all countries that have ratified or joined it. Instead, countries must accept another country’s accession to the Convention before forming a treaty partnership.

3. How Can A Hague Lawyer Help?

A Hague Convention lawyer has experience handling cases related to international child abduction and custody disputes governed by the Hague Convention. They possess in-depth knowledge of the Convention’s provisions, procedures, and legal precedents, enabling them to navigate the complexities of your case effectively. Here’s how a Hague lawyer can assist you:

  • International Legal Aid: Hague lawyers often have established networks of lawyers and resources worldwide, facilitating communication and collaboration across international borders.
  • Negotiation and Mediation: A Hague lawyer can represent your interests during negotiations. Reaching an amicable resolution through negotiation or mediation is preferable to lengthy court proceedings.
  • Court Representation: If your case proceeds to court, your Hague lawyer will advocate on your behalf, presenting compelling arguments and evidence to support your child’s return to their country of habitual residence.

4. How Long Is The Hague Convention Process?

Contrary to common belief, the Hague Convention doesn’t guarantee the automatic return of a child in every case. While it provides a legal framework for facilitating such returns, various circumstances, defenses, and exceptions may complicate matters. Some cases can be resolved relatively quickly, within weeks or months.

While others may drag on longer, especially if they involve complex legal proceedings or appeals, one exception is when there are genuine concerns about the child’s safety or well-being. In such cases, the Hague Convention prioritizes the child’s welfare and safety. Working with a Hague lawyer can help you understand what steps to take to get the swift and safe return of your child.

5. What Steps Should I Take If My Child Has Been Wrongfully Taken?

Discovering that your child has been wrongfully taken across borders is a harrowing experience. Acting swiftly and decisively is crucial if you are in this unfortunate situation. Here are essential steps to consider as you navigate this distressing ordeal:

  • Consult with a Hague Lawyer: Seek legal advice from a Hague Convention lawyer. They can assess your case and guide you through the legal process.
  • File a Hague Application: Depending on your country of residence, you may need to apply the Hague Convention through the appropriate central authority. Your lawyer can assist you with completing and submitting the necessary documentation.
  • Gather Evidence: Collect evidence supporting your claim. This includes documentation of your custody rights, evidence of the child’s habitual residence, and communication with the other party regarding the abduction.
  • Cooperate with Authorities: Work closely with law enforcement, central authorities, and Hague lawyers involved in your case. Provide them with any requested information or assistance to facilitate the prompt resolution.

Finding Legal Representation

Selecting a Hague lawyer familiar with state, federal, and international laws is crucial. Masters Law Group attorneys Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph have years of experience handling Hague Convention cases. Our experience in the Hague Convention field shows our competence in providing legal counsel for these stressful scenarios.

For more information, here are a few of our highlighted Hague Convention cases:

Contact our office today to schedule your consultation.

Sophie Turner and Joe Jonas Case: RESOLVED

In recent legal proceedings, celebrity couple Sophie Turner and Joe Jonas have resolved their dispute over child custody. Turner originally initiated proceedings under The Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction.

The Hague Convention was brought to Jonas via The Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (“The Hague Convention”) enacted into law through the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (“ICARA”). The multi-treaty act provides a parent whose child has been wrongfully removed from or retained in the United States the right to petition for the child’s/children’s return to his or her country of habitual residence. However, the couple has since agreed on a parenting plan that they both agree with. The international child abduction lawsuit has since been dismissed, marking a significant step in resolving their custody issues. This development emphasizes the importance of constructive dialogue in custody disputes. 

HOW IT BEGAN: Mediation Session

Sophie Turner and Joe Jonas entered a four-day mediation session on October 10, 2023, to address custody matters and establish a parenting plan for their children. As for their long-term arrangement, the estranged couple had to “jointly submit a status report letter” before December 2023 outlining where they stand in the mediation process.

Approximately two weeks after Turner initiated the lawsuit, Jonas and Turner reached a temporary custody agreement concerning their two daughters. Subsequently, Jonas filed for dismissing the custody portion of their divorce case in Florida, citing its resolution. 

Following a productive and successful mediation, Jonas and Turner issued a joint statement expressing their agreement that the children would split their time equally between loving homes in the U.S. and the U.K. They expressed anticipation for their roles as co-parents.

International Child Abduction Suit Dropped

Actress Sophie Turner initiated a Hague Convention petition, alleging that her estranged husband, singer, and actor Joe Jonas, refused to allow their children to return to England with her. In her Hague Convention petition, Turner stated that the couple had intended to raise their daughters in her native country, highlighting their integration into daily life in England.

Navigating international family law, particularly in child custody disputes, can be complex. The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Parental Child Abduction is a vital international treaty aimed at protecting children from abduction across borders. With 101 Contracting States, including the United States and the United Kingdom, the 1980 Hague Convention establishes procedures for the prompt return of children wrongfully removed or retained outside their home country.

Subsequently, the “Game of Thrones” star sought to dismiss the lawsuit she filed in September 2023. Legal representatives for the former couple presented new documents to the New York judge overseeing the case, requesting its dismissal in light of an agreed-upon parenting plan. On January 17, the case was officially closed.

Privacy In Hague Convention Cases

In cases involving parental child abduction under the Hague Convention, privacy preservation is paramount. The Hague Convention proceedings typically occur in closed sessions, protecting sensitive family matters from media scrutiny and public exposure.

Unlike traditional courtroom battles where personal details are dissected and presented as evidence, The Hague Convention focuses on resolving disputes while respecting the privacy and dignity of the involved parties. This approach allows individuals to maintain control over the disclosure of personal information.

For high-profile couples like Sophie Turner and Joe Jonas, who often face intense media attention, opting for Hague Convention mediation can mitigate public sensationalism and protect their family’s privacy. By choosing this route, they can shield their child from unnecessary public scrutiny and maintain privacy amidst the legal proceedings.

Child-Focused Strategy

Regardless of the case’s profile, it’s imperative to maintain a child-centered approach throughout legal proceedings. A child-focused strategy is critical when it concerns the Hague Convention and parental child abduction. Dealing with parental child abduction, whether within the U.S. or internationally, presents significant challenges for parents and children. Seeking legal assistance is crucial in effectively navigating parental child abduction cases.

This approach often leads to more enduring and child-friendly resolutions tailored to meet the unique needs and circumstances of the children involved. By centering discussions on the well-being and future of the children, Family Law Attorneys strive to offer legal guidance that is both compassionate and comprehensive in addressing family disputes.

CHALLENGES AND CONSIDERATIONS

If your child is taken to another country, a child abduction attorney can help you navigate The Hague Convention. The Hague Convention is an international treaty designed to facilitate children’s safe return. Taking proactive measures is paramount to protecting your child’s well-being. A parenting plan will give you and your child an added layer of protection should they be abducted.

LAST THOUGHTS

Sophie Turner and Joe Jonas’s decision to pursue mediation to address their custody issues and create a new parenting plan is commendable. It showcases their commitment to providing their children with a stable and loving environment while preserving their privacy and control. Mediation can be a valuable tool for all parents, whether in the public eye or not.

Sophie and Joe’s actions serve as a reminder that prioritizing child-centered solutions is attainable, even amidst the glare of Hollywood. In cases involving the Hague Convention and parental child abduction, this approach underscores the importance of placing the well-being of the children at the forefront of legal proceedings.

Read the People article here for the full timeline of events regarding the Turner and Jonas Divorce.

STAY UP TO DATE WITH MASTERS LAW GROUP

Keeping yourself informed about legal developments is crucial, especially in areas as intricate as divorce mediation, parental child abduction, and parenting time conflicts. The Jonas/Turner case is just one example of the complex issues that can arise in these matters.

By staying updated, you empower yourself with the knowledge to help you make informed decisions about your legal situation.

Hague Convention Law for Parental Child Abduction

Family abductions account for 49 percent of all child abduction cases. Addressing the distressing issue of parental child abduction entails substantial emotional and legal consequences for all parties involved. 

The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction was established in 1980 and entered into force between the signatories on 1 December 1983 to address the complex issue of international parental child abduction. 

In this blog, we will explore the key aspects of the Hague Convention, shedding light on how a family law attorney can play a crucial role in helping navigate these delicate cases.

UNDERSTANDING PARENTAL CHILD ABDUCTION

International parental child abduction is a distressing problem that impacts families worldwide. This issue has profound emotional, psychological, and legal implications for those involved. Due to the increase in international travel, parental child abduction cases have increased, too. But what is categorized as International Parental Child Abduction?

As per Travel.State.Gov, international parental child abduction is the removal or retention of a child outside their country of habitual residence in breach of another parent or guardian’s custody rights. The Office of Children’s Issues within the U.S. Department of State is a leader in U.S. government efforts to prevent international parental child abduction (both from the United States and to the United States), help children and families involved in abduction cases, and promote the objectives of the Hague Abduction Convention.

THE HAGUE CONVENTION & PARENTAL CHILD ABDUCTION

The Hague Convention provides a framework for cooperation between signatory countries in resolving international child abduction cases. This multilateral agreement establishes guidelines for the prompt return of wrongfully removed or retained children. Child abduction attorneys with experience in The Hague Convention can guide families through the legal process to help maximize the chances of a successful outcome. Here are a few ways a Child Abduction Lawyer can help:

  • Legal Experience: A child abduction attorney with experience handling Hague Convention cases possesses in-depth knowledge of the legal framework surrounding international child abduction issues.
  • Prevention Strategies: They can set proactive measures to prevent child abduction. This includes obtaining court orders, creating detailed parenting plans, and securing necessary travel permissions.
  • Hague Convention Compliance: A knowledgeable attorney can guide parents through initiating Hague Convention proceedings, helping to ensure that all necessary documents and evidence are prepared and presented per the Convention’s requirements.
  • Timely Response: Swift action is crucial in child abduction cases. A dedicated attorney can expedite the legal process, filing petitions promptly and coordinating with relevant authorities to locate and return the child promptly.

The Hague Convention works with central authorities to help foster communication and coordinate for the child’s safe return. Let’s take a look at what the central authorities can do.

THE CENTRAL AUTHORITY’S ROLE

Each signatory country designates a Central Authority as a point of contact for international child abduction cases. The Central Authority is crucial in facilitating communication and cooperation between countries involved in resolving these cases.

  • Communication: The Central Authority is a liaison between the left-behind parent and the foreign country. They work closely with other countries to exchange information, coordinate legal proceedings, and help communication.
  • Receiving and Processing Applications: When a parent seeks the return of their child under the Hague Convention, they apply to their home country’s Central Authority. The Central Authority receives and processes these applications, verifying their completeness and compliance with the requirements of the Convention.
  • Initiating Legal Proceedings: Once the Central Authority receives a complete application, they initiate legal proceedings in the country where the child is.
  • Information and Guidance: The Central Authority helps parents through legal procedures and obligations under the Hague Convention to be well-informed throughout the process.
  • International Cooperation: Central Authorities also engage in international cooperation to enhance the effectiveness of the Hague Convention. They participate in conferences, meetings, and training programs to exchange knowledge, share best practices, and strengthen the global network of Central Authorities.

Remember that the specific functions and procedures of the Central Authority may vary slightly between countries. To obtain accurate and country-specific information, consulting with an attorney with experience in international child abduction cases is essential.

HOW A FAMILY LAW ATTORNEY CAN HELP

Addressing issues beyond national borders necessitates efficient coordination with authorities from different countries. This coordination helps individuals navigate high-stakes proceedings seamlessly. Family law attorneys with experience in international abduction cases understand the Hague Convention’s intricacies and relevant international family law.

A skilled family law attorney can adeptly engage with international legal channels to apply the Hague Convention properly. At Masters Law Group, our steadfast attorneys work with local authorities in the abductor’s destination country to monitor compliance with court orders. This allows us to take necessary actions to help facilitate the child’s return if there are any obstacles or delays. 

WORKING WITH MASTERS LAW GROUP

It is important to work with legal professionals who understand the importance of the safety and well-being of your child. Masters Law Group, led by Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph, is experienced in handling delicate, time-sensitive matters involving international parental child abduction. Our attorneys are highly skilled in these areas, litigating in the State of Illinois and the United States federal court system.

See Our Featured Hague Decisions Here:

FINAL THOUGHTS

The Hague Convention provides a framework for addressing parental child abduction on an international scale. In these high-stakes situations, the experience of a family law attorney can be beneficial in initiating the safe return of your child or children. 

Contact us today to set up your complimentary consultation.

Navigating The Hague Convention in 2024

The Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (“The Hague Convention”) plays a pivotal role in addressing the legal complexities arising from cross-border issues regarding Parental Child Abduction.  

The Hague Convention can help untangle the intricate web of cross-border family law disputes. As we usher in the new year, understanding the importance of this international treaty is paramount. Here’s what you need to know.

Understanding The Hague Convention

The Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (“The Hague Convention”) that was enacted into law through the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (“ICARA”) which provides that a parent whose child has been wrongfully removed from or retained in the United States may petition for the child’s return to his or her country of habitual residence.

The Convention is guided by several key principles that shape its framework for addressing international family law issues:

  • Jurisdiction: One of the fundamental principles of the Hague Convention is determining the appropriate jurisdiction for handling international family law matters. It allows cases to be heard in the country where the child has the closest connections.
  • Return of Abducted Children: The Hague Convention is instrumental in cases of international parental child abduction. It provides a legal framework for the prompt return of children who have been unlawfully removed or retained in another country.
  • Recognition of Foreign Decisions: The treaty helps facilitate recognizing and enforcing foreign court decisions related to family law matters, such as divorces and parenting plans.
  • Cooperation Among Signatory States: The Hague Convention relies on the cooperation of the signatory states to help ensure the effective implementation of its principles. Member countries are expected to work together to resolve cross-border family law disputes.

The Impact of the Hague Convention in 2024

In 2024, the Hague Convention continues to be a strong tool for addressing the increasing challenges posed by international family law issues. Here are some key points to consider when navigating its provisions:

  • Legal Representation: Individuals involved in international family law disputes should seek legal representation experienced in handling cases under the convention. Legal professionals experienced in The Hague Convention  can help navigate the complex procedures and protect your rights.
  • Compliance with Local Laws: While the Hague Convention provides a framework for resolving international family law disputes, it’s essential to remember that local laws and regulations can still impact the outcome of a case. Understanding both international and local legal requirements is crucial.
  • Timely Action: In cases involving the abduction of a child across borders, taking timely action is of utmost importance. The Hague Convention emphasizes the need for swift resolution to minimize the disruption and distress experienced by the child.

Hague Convention Legal Assistance And Representation

Parents involved in international child abduction cases should seek the assistance of an attorney experienced in the Hague Convention. These attorneys possess the knowledge and experience to guide parents through the legal process and protect their rights. 

If you have concerns about the abduction of your child, you should take appropriate proactive measures to protect their well-being. An experienced Hague Convention lawyer can help and may recommend several preventative measures, such as:

  1. Obtaining a custody order or parenting plan that clearly outlines each parent’s rights and responsibilities, including travel restrictions.
  2. Adding your child’s name to a watchlist to prevent unauthorized removal from the country.
  3. Obtaining a court order requires surrendering your child’s passport or imposing restrictions on international travel.
  4. Collaborating with your child’s school or daycare to establish security measures and emergency protocols.

If you have concerns about parental child abduction, promptly contacting your family law attorney is of utmost importance. They will discuss your options with you and assist in developing a plan that prioritizes your child’s safety.

Working With a Hague Convention Attorney

Senior attorneys Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph have years of experience in cases involving international parental responsibility disputes in the State of Illinois and the United States federal court systems. With our firm’s experience, you can trust that we will tirelessly advocate on your behalf for you and your child/children.

To showcase our competence, here are some important recent Hague decisions we have successfully handled:

Final Thoughts

As we move through the new year, we must continue to familiarize ourselves with The Hague Convention. This principal treaty remains a cornerstone of international family law. Whether you are dealing with divorce, parental responsibility disputes, or parental child abduction issues, understanding the intricacies of the Hague Convention is an essential step for navigating the complexities of this rising family law crime.

If you or a loved one is facing the distressing possibility of international parental child abduction, please don’t hesitate to contact us. Take the first step by scheduling your consultation with us here today.