Tag Archive for: Global hague lawyer

Sophie Turner and Joe Jonas Case: RESOLVED

In recent legal proceedings, celebrity couple Sophie Turner and Joe Jonas have resolved their dispute over child custody. Turner originally initiated proceedings under The Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction.

The Hague Convention was brought to Jonas via The Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (“The Hague Convention”) enacted into law through the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (“ICARA”). The multi-treaty act provides a parent whose child has been wrongfully removed from or retained in the United States the right to petition for the child’s/children’s return to his or her country of habitual residence. However, the couple has since agreed on a parenting plan that they both agree with. The international child abduction lawsuit has since been dismissed, marking a significant step in resolving their custody issues. This development emphasizes the importance of constructive dialogue in custody disputes. 

HOW IT BEGAN: Mediation Session

Sophie Turner and Joe Jonas entered a four-day mediation session on October 10, 2023, to address custody matters and establish a parenting plan for their children. As for their long-term arrangement, the estranged couple had to “jointly submit a status report letter” before December 2023 outlining where they stand in the mediation process.

Approximately two weeks after Turner initiated the lawsuit, Jonas and Turner reached a temporary custody agreement concerning their two daughters. Subsequently, Jonas filed for dismissing the custody portion of their divorce case in Florida, citing its resolution. 

Following a productive and successful mediation, Jonas and Turner issued a joint statement expressing their agreement that the children would split their time equally between loving homes in the U.S. and the U.K. They expressed anticipation for their roles as co-parents.

International Child Abduction Suit Dropped

Actress Sophie Turner initiated a Hague Convention petition, alleging that her estranged husband, singer, and actor Joe Jonas, refused to allow their children to return to England with her. In her Hague Convention petition, Turner stated that the couple had intended to raise their daughters in her native country, highlighting their integration into daily life in England.

Navigating international family law, particularly in child custody disputes, can be complex. The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Parental Child Abduction is a vital international treaty aimed at protecting children from abduction across borders. With 101 Contracting States, including the United States and the United Kingdom, the 1980 Hague Convention establishes procedures for the prompt return of children wrongfully removed or retained outside their home country.

Subsequently, the “Game of Thrones” star sought to dismiss the lawsuit she filed in September 2023. Legal representatives for the former couple presented new documents to the New York judge overseeing the case, requesting its dismissal in light of an agreed-upon parenting plan. On January 17, the case was officially closed.

Privacy In Hague Convention Cases

In cases involving parental child abduction under the Hague Convention, privacy preservation is paramount. The Hague Convention proceedings typically occur in closed sessions, protecting sensitive family matters from media scrutiny and public exposure.

Unlike traditional courtroom battles where personal details are dissected and presented as evidence, The Hague Convention focuses on resolving disputes while respecting the privacy and dignity of the involved parties. This approach allows individuals to maintain control over the disclosure of personal information.

For high-profile couples like Sophie Turner and Joe Jonas, who often face intense media attention, opting for Hague Convention mediation can mitigate public sensationalism and protect their family’s privacy. By choosing this route, they can shield their child from unnecessary public scrutiny and maintain privacy amidst the legal proceedings.

Child-Focused Strategy

Regardless of the case’s profile, it’s imperative to maintain a child-centered approach throughout legal proceedings. A child-focused strategy is critical when it concerns the Hague Convention and parental child abduction. Dealing with parental child abduction, whether within the U.S. or internationally, presents significant challenges for parents and children. Seeking legal assistance is crucial in effectively navigating parental child abduction cases.

This approach often leads to more enduring and child-friendly resolutions tailored to meet the unique needs and circumstances of the children involved. By centering discussions on the well-being and future of the children, Family Law Attorneys strive to offer legal guidance that is both compassionate and comprehensive in addressing family disputes.

CHALLENGES AND CONSIDERATIONS

If your child is taken to another country, a child abduction attorney can help you navigate The Hague Convention. The Hague Convention is an international treaty designed to facilitate children’s safe return. Taking proactive measures is paramount to protecting your child’s well-being. A parenting plan will give you and your child an added layer of protection should they be abducted.

LAST THOUGHTS

Sophie Turner and Joe Jonas’s decision to pursue mediation to address their custody issues and create a new parenting plan is commendable. It showcases their commitment to providing their children with a stable and loving environment while preserving their privacy and control. Mediation can be a valuable tool for all parents, whether in the public eye or not.

Sophie and Joe’s actions serve as a reminder that prioritizing child-centered solutions is attainable, even amidst the glare of Hollywood. In cases involving the Hague Convention and parental child abduction, this approach underscores the importance of placing the well-being of the children at the forefront of legal proceedings.

Read the People article here for the full timeline of events regarding the Turner and Jonas Divorce.

STAY UP TO DATE WITH MASTERS LAW GROUP

Keeping yourself informed about legal developments is crucial, especially in areas as intricate as divorce mediation, parental child abduction, and parenting time conflicts. The Jonas/Turner case is just one example of the complex issues that can arise in these matters.

By staying updated, you empower yourself with the knowledge to help you make informed decisions about your legal situation.

Red Flags for Parental Child Abduction

Parental child abduction is the removal or retention of a child outside of their habitual residence in breach of another parent or guardian’s custody rights. This can be a deeply distressing and complex issue that can lead to intricate legal battles.

At Masters Law Group, we’ve witnessed the anguish and legal complexities that arise in such situations. We believe that the best approach is proactive prevention. Today, we will shed light on some red flags you should be aware of when it comes to parental child abduction, and provide actionable steps to take if your child is at risk. 

Before we begin, if you are facing a family abduction matter, call the police immediately. These cases are treated very seriously, and many AMBER alerts stem from family abductions. Even where the child may not face an imminent threat of physical harm, law enforcement will treat these types of abductions as high priorities and will work to return the child to his or her parent.

Here is what you need to know.

STATISTICS ON PARENTAL CHILD ABDUCTION

Most children abducted today are not taken by strangers, they are taken by their parents. The motivations behind parental child abduction can vary widely, from custody disputes to cultural differences. To gain a deeper understanding of these motivations, consider these statistics:

  • Approximately eight out of every ten parents who choose to abduct their child do so to affect custodial privileges permanently.
  • Three out of every four parents who choose to abduct their children do so to limit contact between the child and the custodial parent.
  • Approximately 65% of parents that abduct their children and just recently had a change in their visitation rights.
  • 15% of children who are abducted by a parent were taken from another relative or foster parents.

RED FLAGS FOR PARENTAL CHILD ABDUCTION

Being able to identify the red flags that signal parental child abduction is crucial when it comes to preventing these heartbreaking scenarios. Here are some key indicators to be aware of:

  1. Threats and Previous Incidents: Taking any previous threats of hiding your child is vital, as these behaviors can escalate to abduction.
  2. Weak Ties to Current Location: Parents with limited connections to their current community, unstable employment, or distant family may feel more inclined to relocate with the child.
  3. Strong Affiliation with Another Country: Keep an eye on parents with strong emotional or familial ties to another country, especially if they have lived there previously or frequently express a desire to return.
  4. Recent Unexplained Changes in Behavior: Sudden and unexplained actions like quitting a job, selling property, closing bank accounts, or applying for passports or visas should raise concerns, as they could indicate plans for abduction.
  5. History of Relationship Struggles or Domestic Violence: In some cases, parents who perceive themselves as wronged in the relationship may resort to abduction as a means of retaliation. Understanding this history can help identify potential risks early on.

By recognizing these red flags, we can take proactive steps to protect our children and prevent the devastating consequences of parental child abduction.

STEPS TO TAKE IF YOU SUSPECT A RISK

The unsettling possibility of parental child abduction is a stark reality for some families. Recognizing the warning signs and proactively safeguarding your child’s well-being is essential. Below, you’ll find critical steps to follow if you suspect the risk of abduction:

  1. Collecting Evidence: Documenting any threats or unusual behavior is a crucial first step in building a solid case to protect your child. Saving relevant electronic communications can provide invaluable evidence.
  2. Alerting Authorities: If you believe an abduction is coming, informing law enforcement and legal authorities is critical.
  3. Consulting with a Family Law Attorney: A family law attorney with experience in parental abduction matters is highly recommended. They can guide you through the complex legal processes.

INTERNATIONAL PARENTAL CHILD ABDUCTION CASES

Sometimes, a parent will attempt to take their child out of their home country. This can add even more complexity to an already sensitive and difficult situation. The Hauge Convention was enacted into law through the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (ICARA) which provides that a parent whose child has been wrongfully removed or retained may petition for the child’s return to their country of habitual residence. This method has proven safe and highly effective in reuniting these children with their families.

WORKING WITH A CHILD ABDUCTION ATTORNEY

Parental child abduction is a serious matter that requires proactive attention and sensitivity. By staying vigilant and recognizing the warning signs, you can take steps to help prevent it. At Masters Law Group, our family law attorneys are here to provide you with legal knowledge and support during these challenging times. 

Legal matters often come with complexities and long-lasting implications for all parties involved. A family law attorney can streamline these processes, helping expedite your legal concerns. Beyond their grasp of the law, child abduction attorneys offer personalized strategic advice tailored to your unique circumstances. 

Our child abduction attorneys have achieved multiple successful parental child abduction cases, including:

FINAL THOUGHTS

Parental child abduction cases are complex, and the stakes are high. Seeking the assistance of a child abduction attorney is a crucial step in helping to ensure the safe recovery of your child. Taking swift action is necessary if you ever face a child abduction scenario.

If your child is taken across national borders, initiate a Hague Convention application with your attorney immediately.

Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph are highly experienced in handling disputes related to international parental child abduction, particularly within the jurisdiction of the State of Illinois and the United States federal court system. 

Voted 2023’s Best Lawyers® in America 2023, Masters Law Group is focused on achieving the best possible result for our clients and, more importantly, any children involved. 

Contact us to set up a complimentary consultation today to discuss your situation.

Family Child Abduction

The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children estimates that approximately 200,000 of the 260,000 children abducted each year are taken by a parent or other family member. Family Child Abduction is a very serious criminal offense that can have devastating effects on children and parents.

Family child abduction is illegal in every state, and it is often treated as a felony-level offense that can result in prison upon conviction. In many cases, family abductions occur in the midst of bitter divorce or child custody battles. The child may be kept beyond a court allotted visitation period or the parent may pick up the child from school or daycare without permission and not return the child. In other cases, a child may be abducted by a family member and may face physical or sexual abuse.

The Frightening Family Abduction Statistics

David Finkelhor, director of the Crimes against Children Research Center at the University of New Hampshire, led a team of researchers who sought a better estimate of the prevalence of family abduction. They used data from three waves of the National Surveys of Children’s Exposure to Violence (NatSCEV), sponsored by the U.S. Department of Justice and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. In 2008, 2011 and 2014, the surveys asked children aged 10 to 17 years about their life experiences. Information about children aged 9 and younger was gathered from caregivers.

Some key findings:

  • 4 percent of children in the sample had experienced family abduction and 1.2 percent had experienced it within the past year. Based on this information, the researchers estimate that 875,000 children a year – 12 per 1,000 — are either abducted by a relative.
  • Parents were the perpetrators in more than 90 percent of abductions. Mothers and female family members were responsible for the majority – 60 percent. However, fathers and male relatives were responsible for 64 percent of all abductions.
  • Children who have been abducted are more likely to be from low-income households and have separated, estranged or divorced parents. In two-parent families, an estimated nine children per 1,000 experience an abduction compared to 84 per 1,000 in single-parent households.
  • 43 percent of abductions were reported to the police, including 86 percent of family abductions.

If you are facing a family abduction matter, call the police immediately. These cases are treated very seriously and many AMBER alerts that are issued stem from family abductions. Even where the child may not face an imminent threat of physical harm, law enforcement will treat these types of abductions as high priorities and will work to return the child to his or her parent.

International Family Abductions

International child abduction is a distressing problem that impacts numerous families worldwide. This issue has profound emotional, psychological, and legal implications for those involved. Due to the increasing ease of international travel, these cases are sadly on the rise.

But what classifies as International Parental Child Abduction? As per Travel.State.Gov, international parental child abduction is the removal or retention of a child outside their country of habitual residence in breach of another parent or guardian’s custody rights.  The Office of Children’s Issues within the U.S. Department of State is a leader in U.S. government efforts to prevent international parental child abduction (both from the United States and to the United States), help children and families involved in abduction cases, and promote the objectives of the Hague Abduction Convention.

Causes and Factors of International Child Abduction

A variety of factors drive international child abduction. Child abduction often occurs after separations, divorces, or custody disputes. Let’s take a look at some additional factors that contribute to international child abduction:

  • Cultural and Economic Reasons: Globalization and increased international mobility have prompted some parents to return to their native countries, often taking their children. These reasons are often influenced by a desire to maintain cultural connections, be closer to extended family, or seek better economic opportunities in their home nation.
  • Fear of Child’s Well-being: Concerns about the child’s safety in the other parent’s environment can drive some parents to abduct their child when they believe it offers better conditions.
  • Parental Alienation: In some cases, one parent might feel alienated from the child due to actual or perceived biases in the custody proceedings. Parental Alienation can foster desperation, prompting the alienated parent to resort to drastic measures like abduction to regain control over the situation.
  • Lack of Robust Legal Framework: Different legal systems and international treaties across countries are challenging. Not all countries are part of the Hague Convention of Civil Aspects. The lack of a legal framework in certain countries creates loopholes that abducting parents might exploit. The absence of streamlined procedures for cross-border child custody disputes can complicate efforts to prevent international abduction.

To effectively tackle the underlying issues of international child abduction, it’s essential to take a thorough approach. An effective process might involve enhancing parents’ communication and establishing robust support systems. We can work together to prevent the detrimental effects of international child abduction families by addressing these factors across borders.

Preventing  Child Abduction

When parents can’t agree on where a child should live, working with an attorney experienced in child abductions can help. If you think the other parent has taken your child, here’s what you can do:

  1. Get a Court Order or Custody Decree: It’s essential to have a clear court order that outlines custody arrangements and travel restrictions. This order can help prevent unwanted travel with the child. Court orders can also address matters like passports and custody details.
  2. Consult a Child Abduction Attorney: Talk to an attorney who knows about these situations. They can help you understand your options and might suggest getting an order that stops the child from leaving the country.
  3. Look for Warning Signs: Watch for sudden changes in the other parent’s life, like quitting a job or selling a home. These changes could indicate plans to move. You can find more information on our Resources for Parents page.
  4. Tell the Police and Share Court Orders: Inform the local police about the situation and give them copies of your court orders, including any custody, protection, or restraining orders you have.
  5. Contact a Foreign Embassy or Consulate: If your child is a dual national of another country, consider contacting that country’s embassy or consulate.
  6. Know About Travel Rules: The United States doesn’t have strict rules for children leaving the country. Even without both parents’ agreement, a child can cross borders. Without a clear court order saying otherwise, it can be challenging for law enforcement to stop an abduction.

If you believe your child has been abducted, always start by calling the police.

Work With a Child Abduction Attorney 

Dealing with international child abduction situations presents significant challenges for parents and children. Seeking the assistance of a child abduction attorney is a crucial step in ensuring the safe recovery of your child.

Taking swift action is necessary if you ever face a child abduction case. In such situations, partnering with an experienced child abduction attorney is needed. Their experience becomes crucial for initiating a Hague Convention application for scaling a defense against any Hague Convention-related legal actions. 

Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph are highly experienced in handling disputes related to international child abduction, particularly within the jurisdiction of the State of Illinois and the United States federal court system. Voted 2023’s Best Lawyers® in America 2023, Masters Law Group is focused on solving problems and achieving the best possible result for our clients, and more importantly, any children involved. 

Contact us to set up a complimentary consultation today to discuss your situation.

Child Abduction Lawyer

The nightmare of a child abduction is a situation no parent ever wants to face. The feeling of helplessness can be overwhelming, but immediate action is essential to ensure your child’s safe return. 

Illinois courts regard child abduction with utmost severity. Child abduction is a serious crime that can have a significant impact on the well-being of a child. Similarly, parents of a child who’s been abducted suffer greatly.

Child abduction or child theft is the unauthorized removal of a minor from the custody of the child’s natural parents or legally appointed guardians. A stranger might abduct a child for criminal activities, including sexual exploitation, extortion, ransom, or worse. Some strangers may abduct with the intent to raise the child as if it were their own. Additionally, during divorce proceedings, one parent might take away a child without the other parent’s consent.

In cases involving international abduction, the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction provides a framework for cooperation among countries. 

UNDERSTANDING CHILD ABDUCTION

Child abduction is a distressing problem that impacts numerous families. Every thousand children are abducted by a family member each year. Almost 5% of children in the US have experienced a parental abduction in their lifetime.

Child abduction is when someone (a stranger or family member) takes a child without legal permission, causing great distress and separation from the family. These frightening situations also occur worldwide, impacting families across the globe. In such complex cases, seeking the assistance of a child abduction attorney becomes vital. Let’s look at some steps you can take to help you move through this frightening situation.

IMMEDIATE STEPS TO TAKE

If you are in a heartbreaking situation of suspecting that your child has been abducted, taking swift and strategic action is crucial. Begin by immediately contacting your local law enforcement agency to report the abduction. Provide them with all available information about your child, including:

  • Recent photographs
  • Physical characteristics such as height, weight, and eye color.
  • Any psychical features that might help identify them.

Simultaneously, gather any evidence that could be helpful in the investigation. Evidence could include potential witnesses, last-known locations, and any communication you might have had with the abductor. While child abduction is incredibly distressing, reaching out to your support networks is essential to ensure you have emotional and logistical assistance. Acting promptly and systematically can significantly improve your child’s safe and timely recovery. 

Several factors influence the determination of the necessary actions to take. Working alongside a child abduction attorney with experience in the Hague Convention can be highly beneficial throughout this time.

UNDERSTANDING THE Hague Convention

In cases involving international abduction, the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction provides a framework for cooperation among countries. The Convention’s framework enables countries to collaborate to solve complex custody cases involving child abduction. 

The Convention doesn’t rely on the immigration status or nationality of the child. In certain situations, a country might wrongfully detain a child if they are not a resident. Violations of custodial rights occur when the child is taken away from their customary home and is now residing in a foreign country.

The Central Authority has the following responsibilities:

  • Serve as the point of contact for parents and children in international child custody cases.
  • Aid in locating abducted children.
  • Promote solutions that consider the best interests of both parents.
  • Submit documents as part of the application that are admissible in courts of partner countries.

To prove that a parent’s custodial rights were violated when the child was taken from their country, presenting a custody order is unnecessary; proof of parenthood or marriage can verify this. The return of a child to their habitual residence is not contingent on the immigration status or nationality of the child or their parents.

Working with a child abduction attorney can provide valuable help. Child abduction attorneys are critical in ensuring children’s safety and well-being. Their ability to support the children and the troubled families caught in such distressing situations is admirable and comforting.

GETTING HELP FROM A FAMILY LAW ATTORNEY

If you face such a child abduction case, you must act fast. A family law attorney experienced with child abductions must be ready to file a Hague Convention application and defend a Hague Convention lawsuit on short notice. Because of this, locating counsel with knowledge and experience in Hague proceedings is vital. 

Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph have extensive experience in cases involving international child abduction disputes in the State of Illinois and the United States federal court system. 

Feel free to explore our recent featured Hague Decisions:

FINAL THOUGHTS

Are you facing or at risk of the daunting scenario of child abduction? Don’t navigate this complex journey alone. Take the first step toward securing your child’s safety and well-being by reaching out to our dedicated lawyers at Masters Law Group. 

If you need a child abduction lawyer with substantial experience in dealing with child abduction cases, contact us today to schedule your consultation.

Debunking Common Myths About The Hague Convention

The Hague Convention has gained widespread attention across the globe, yet many parents in the United States still have much to discover when it comes to its true purpose and potential in Parental Child Abduction. 

The Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction is a treaty that many countries, including the United States, have joined.

The purpose of the Convention is to protect children from the harmful effects of international abduction by a parent by encouraging the prompt return of abducted children to their country of habitual residence and to organize or secure the effective rights of access to a child. The idea is that custody and visitation matters should generally be decided by the proper court in the country of the child’s habitual residence.

Today, we debunk myths and show you how the convention can be beneficial. Here’s what you need to know.

Myth 1: The Hague Convention is only applicable in cases of child abduction

One of the most common misunderstandings surrounding The Hague Convention is the belief that it is limited to international child abduction cases. While it is true that the convention places significant emphasis on addressing child abduction, its reach extends far beyond this context. The Hague Convention also addresses other critical aspects related to the well-being of children.

An important objective of The Hague Convention is to swiftly return children who have been wrongfully removed or retained by one parent without the consent of the other. This provision helps ensure that children are kept from their custodial parent in a foreign jurisdiction with a proper legal basis.

Furthermore, The Hague Convention recognizes the importance of regular contact and access between children and both of their parents when living in separate nations. This provision promotes a balanced approach that seeks to preserve meaningful relationships and minimize disruptions in a child’s life.

Myth 2: The Hague Convention automatically guarantees the return of a child

Contrary to popular belief, the Hague Convention does not guarantee the automatic return of a child in all cases. However, it is essential to understand that the convention has a legal framework for facilitating the return of a child. But certain circumstances, defenses and exceptions may arise.

One exception is when there is a genuine concern of physical or psychological harm to the child if they were to be returned to their country of habitual residence. The Hague Convention recognizes the importance of the child’s well-being and safety. 

If it can be established that there is a grave risk of harm, the courts may decide not to order the child’s return, prioritizing their best interests. The convention strives to strike a delicate balance between facilitating the return of children in most cases while safeguarding their well-being and protecting their fundamental rights.

Myth 3: The Hague Convention favors mothers over fathers

Another common misconception is that the Hague Convention tends toward mothers over fathers. However, the gender-neutral convention aims to protect the child’s best interests rather than select one parent. It emphasizes the importance of maintaining regular contact between the child and both parents, assuming no risks to the child’s well-being.

The Hague Convention recognizes that children benefit from having a meaningful and ongoing relationship with both parents. It promotes the principle of shared parental responsibility and seeks to maintain regular contact between the child and both parents, irrespective of gender. The convention operates under the assumption that the involvement of both parents contributes to the child’s well-being and healthy development.

When a case arises under The Hague Convention, the focus is not on selecting one parent over the other. Ultimately, the court will determine what arrangement best serves the child’s best interests. The courts consider various factors, such as

  • The child’s age.
  • Attachments and mental stability.
  • The ability of each parent to provide a nurturing environment.

The goal is to arrive at a decision that ensures the child’s overall welfare and enables them to maintain a meaningful relationship with both parents.

Myth 4: The Hague Convention is impossible to navigate

The Hague Convention can vary depending on factors such as legal representation and the case’s complexity. However, the convention also encourages countries to assist parents lacking resources, ensuring that constraints do not impede access to justice.

These central authorities are vital in facilitating communication and cooperation between the countries involved in a case. They work together to locate the child, gather necessary information, and resolve the situation quickly. The Hague Convention highlights the importance of minimizing a child’s time separated from their custodial parent. This allows them to maintain stability in their lives.

Furthermore, the U.S. Department of State and an experienced Family Law Firm dedicated to International Parental Child Abduction cases can also help to enforce the safe return of your child or children.

Myth 5: The Hague Convention is universally accepted and followed by all countries

One important misconception to address is the belief that The Hague Convention is universally accepted and followed by all countries. While the convention has substantial international recognition, not all nations have ratified or acceded to its provisions. This can create complexities, particularly in cross-border child abduction cases, where one or both countries are non-signatories.

Ninety-three countries have ratified The Hague Convention, demonstrating a widespread acknowledgment of its importance in stopping international parental abduction and related matters. These countries have committed to implementing the convention’s principles and cooperating at every stage to help ensure the prompt return of abducted children.

However, it is crucial to recognize the challenges when dealing with countries that have not fully implemented The Hague Convention. In such cases, the lack of a recognized legal framework can complicate efforts to return an abducted child. This can also alter effective communication and cooperation between jurisdictions.

Final Thoughts

The Hague Convention is a critical international treaty that provides essential protection for children against the detrimental consequences of cross-border abduction and retention. It is vital to distinguish between truth and misinformation to promote a clearer understanding of the convention’s purpose. We can foster greater awareness and appreciation for The Hague Convention by dispelling misconceptions.

Voted Best Law Firm 2023, Masters Law Group is home to the best highly-experienced family law attorneys, Erin E. Masters and Anthony G. Joseph, who possess extensive knowledge in Hague law. Our dedicated team of professionals is well-equipped to navigate the intricate landscape of international law, delivering robust representation in these complex and high-stakes proceedings.

Contact our office today to schedule your consultation and gain valuable insights into your case.

Highlighted Hague Decisions:

What are the Defenses to the Hague Convention?

A parent who moves with a child from the child’s home country to another country may face accusations that the move is wrongful. The Hague Abduction Convention is an international agreement to safeguard intercountry adoptions and parental abductions. 

The Hague Convention is a treaty that the United States has joined, along with many other countries. Its purpose is to protect children from the harmful effects of international abduction by a parent.

When one parent applies to the State Court or Federal Court for return of a child who has been taken from a foreign country and brought to the United States, or is wrongfully retained in the United States beyond the agreed-upon time frame of a temporary absence, that parent may assert certain defenses to prevent the return.

The courts can deny the return of an abducted child under six conditions listed in the Convention, including if a child would be at risk of being subjected to physical or psychological harm, or otherwise placed in an intolerable situation.

Fun Fact: Masters Law Group is highly experienced with Hague Convention cases, with clients not only in the Greater Chicagoland area, but also across the United States in Washington, Hawaii and Wisconsin. 

Here’s what you need to know about the defenses to the Hague Convention.

What is the Hague Convention? 

The Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, codified as ICARA, allows a parent whose child has been wrongfully removed from or retained in the United States to petition for the child’s return to his or her country of habitual residence.

This treaty was developed by the Hague Conference on October 25, 1980, and went into effect on December 1, 1983. There were two specific goals in mind for Hague Services:

  • Create a means to ensure that judicial and extrajudicial documents to be served abroad can be brought to the notice of the addressee in sufficient time.
  • Improve the organization of mutual judicial assistance.

The removal of a child is “wrongful” whenever it breaches the rights of the person who has custody attributed to them at the time of removal. Even if a parent already has legal custody of a child, the Convention is needed. This is because U.S. court orders are not always recognized in other countries and sovereign nations can’t interfere with each other’s legal systems, judiciaries, or law enforcement. 

Under the Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction and the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (ICARA), when a child has been wrongfully removed from his or her home country, the court must order the child to be returned to his or her home country, unless the party removing the child can establish at least one of six narrow affirmative defenses.

Six Defenses of the Hague Convention

Here are the following defenses to claim wrongful removal under the Hague Convention:

Defense 1: That the petitioner (parent seeking the return of the child) was not “actually exercising custody rights at the time of the removal or retention” under Article 13.

Defense 2: That the petitioner “had consented to or acquiesced in the removal or retention” under Article 13.

Defense 3: That more than one year passed from the time of the wrongful removal or retention until the date the petitioner commenced a judicial or administrative proceeding for the return of the child, under Article 12.

Defense 4: That the child is old enough and has a sufficient degree of maturity to knowingly object to being returned to the petitioner and that it is appropriate to heed that objection, under Article 13.

Defense 5: That “there is grave risk that the child’s return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place the child in an intolerable situation,” under Article 13(b), and

Defense 6: That return of the child would subject the child to violation of basic human rights and fundamental freedoms, under Article 20.

It’s important to note, you should make International Custody Agreements & Parenting Time schedules before you relocate your child/children. U.S. Courts will need to determine the best interest of the child before you do so. 

If you believe your child has been wrongfully removed to a country overseas, or if you would like to move your child out of the U.S. you should contact your trusted family law attorney immediately.  Your attorney can explain the proper steps for handling this matter and guide you toward a just outcome.

How Masters Law Group Can Help

Parents face many obstacles when it comes to seeking judicial intervention in the US for the return of their children.  Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph have extensive experience in cases involving international child custody disputes in both courts located in the State of Illinois and the United States federal court system.

Our Family Law Firm has extensive knowledge and experience with The Hague Convention which provides that a parent whose child has been wrongfully removed from or retained in the United States may petition for the child’s return to his or her country of habitual residence. Our clients span across the entire Unites States, from Washington to Wisconsin; so you can rest assured knowing the experienced Masters Law Group attorneys are fighting for you and your family.

Check out our Featured Hague Decisions:

If you are faced with the terrifying scenario of International Parental Child Abduction, contact your trusted Chicago attorneys at Masters Law Group here today to schedule a consultation.

International Parental Abduction

International parental child abduction is an act of illegally taking a child from their home. Usually by one of the parents, but it can also be done by an acquaintance or another member of the family, and taking him to another county. Here’s what you need to know about this growing problem. 

When parents report that their children have been abducted or retained outside of the United States, country officers inform them of potential options and provide resources to help them seek the return of, or access to, their children. International Parental Abduction is more common than you think.

In 2020, country officers responded to 157 initial inquiries in which parents sought information and resources regarding abductions, but did not proceed with providing complete documentation. Country officers handled 664 total outgoing abduction cases, including 246 cases opened in 2020. Of those cases,129 were resolved with the return of 185 abducted children to the United States.

Here’s a look at the Hague Abduction Convention, and what you should know about International Parental Abduction.

Is Your Child at Risk for An International Abduction?

There’s certain traits and characteristics of offending parents that make it easier to spot if they are capable of abduction your child. It is important to remember that these signs do not necessarily mean that your child’s other parent is going to abduct your child; these are signs that you need to make sure you are being more aware of. Here are some examples below:

  • Parents who threaten to abduct their children and/or have abducted their children before.
  • Parents who believe their children are being abused and have a support group that also believes this.
  • Parents with paranoia or sociopathic tendencies.
  • Parents with strong ties and family support in another country.
  • Parents frustrated with the legal system in the United States who have supportive family and friends.

It’s not unusual for a parent who abducts their child to believe that they know what is best for the child. Young children are the easiest to abduct because they don’t know to go for help or do anything to bring attention to their parents taking them.  Some other warning signs and factors that are important to be aware of are:

  • A parent with no source of income/job.
  • A parent who is financially independent.
  • A parent with no real ties to the community they live in.
  • A parent who abruptly quits their job, sells their home, applies for passports.
  • A parent who starts collecting the child’s medical and school records.
  • A parent who has domestic violence and/or child abuse history.

Protecting Your Child From International Parental Abduction

When developing a child custody order, it is important that the order be very specific in regard to the rights of each parent. You should avoid vague phrases like “reasonable visitation” because the word reasonable can be interpreted differently.. Joint custody should also be avoided if there has been any history of abduction or the risk of abduction is high.  

Your court order should include why the court has jurisdiction in the matter of your child and state that both parents were given the opportunity to present their case to the court regarding custody. In order for your court order to be able to be enforced nationwide, the court’s exercise of their jurisdiction has to comply with the federal Parental Kidnapping Prevention Act (PKPA).

Your court order can specify that your child is not allowed to leave the state you reside in without written consent from the other parent.  

The court order can also ban a parent from applying for a passport for your child.  If your child already has a passport, the court can require that the passport be surrendered. If you have information that your child would most likely be taken to a specific country, you can notify that embassy or consulate and provide them with the court order to request any visa requests for your child be denied.

If the risk to your child being abducted by their other parent is high, the court is typically more likely to put protections in the court order to prevent abduction. The court looks at the following factors: risk of abduction is high, recovering the child would be very difficult, and the abduction would be harmful to the child.

Some additional steps to lower the risk of parental abduction or increase your odds recovering your child if they are abducted would be:

  • Have up-to-date pictures of your child.
  • Have a written detailed description of your child including: height, weight, hair color, eye color, birthmarks, and noticeable physical characteristics.
  • Copies of your child’s Social Security card and passport.
  • Fingerprints of your child.
  • Have your child/children learn how to use a telephone and how to call the police.
  • Keep schools, daycares, and other child care providers informed of current custody orders.
  • Register your child with the Children’s Passport Issuance Alert Program (CPIAP).

International Child Abduction Remedies Act (ICARA)


The International Child Abduction Remedies Act (ICARA), is a multi-lateral treaty developed by the Hague Convention on Private International Law.

ICARA is United States federal law that implements the HAC between American states and American states internationally with other countries.  It went into effect in 1988.

When a child is alleged removed from his/her habitual residence, or a parent is not allowed his/her visitation with a child under a previous legal agreement, that child’s parent can now bring an action in local court under ICARA.  After a showing of the other parent’s wrongdoing, the alleged wrongdoer must show to the court one of the following:

  • that the person requesting the return of the child was not actually exercising custody’ at the time of the removal or retention;
  • that the person requesting the return of the child had consented to or acquiesced in the removal or retention;
  • that more than one year has passed from the time of wrongful removal or retention until the date of the commencement of judicial or administrative proceedings;
  • that the child is old enough and has a sufficient degree of maturity to knowingly object to the person requesting the return of the child, and that it is appropriate to heed that objection;
  • that there is grave risk that the child’s return would expose the child to physical or psychological harm or otherwise place the child in an intolerable situation; or
  • that return of the child would subject the child to violation of basic human rights and fundamental freedoms.

Attempting to have one’s child returned to his/her care or to be able to exercise one’s visitation rights either by state to state or from state to an international country is very complicated.  It is highly recommended that a professional family law attorney be retained to navigate the legalities involved.

Child Custody and Visitation Matters


With the exception of international parental abduction, child custody and visitation matters are handled by local and state authorities, and not by the federal government. The matters are governed by the relevant state family court system and human services agency. Therefore, child custody or visitation issues should be reported to state or local law enforcement authorities or a state judicial officer.

In addition to contacting the Department of State, Office of Children’s Issues, law enforcement or left-behind parents should also contact the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (“NCMEC”): www.missingkids.org. NCMEC works closely with the State Department and the U.S. Department of Justice’s Office for Victims of Crime and administers its Victim Reunification Travel Program. Eligible parents can request financial assistance so they can be reunited with a child located in another country or obtain travel support for the child’s return to the United States.

Finally, seeking a family law firm who are highly experienced in cases involving international child custody disputes (in both courts located in the State of Illinois and the United States federal court system) could be an invaluable resource in this incredibly stressful time.

Additional Resources on International Parental Abduction

Final Thoughts

Many countries throughout the world, including the United States, belong to the Hague Convention, and will negotiate treaties to help streamline international justice. When family law disputes cross international boundaries, it is essential to have the help from a knowledgeable family law attorney who understands all of the legalities that go along with international child custody cases.

Our attorneys, Erin Masters and Anthony Joseph, have extensive knowledge and experience with The Hague Convention on Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (“The Hague Convention”) that was enacted into law through the International Child Abduction Remedies Act (“ICARA”). 

See Our Featured Hague Decisions Here:

Contact us here today to learn more.